The CNIL has imposed a €5 million fine on a company that stored its customers’ passwords in plain text, under a decision dated 12 November 2026 and made public on 18 November. The authority did not name the company, but the press has identified it as the insurer Macif Vie: according to Siècle Digital, Macif confirmed to BFM Tech that it was the company sanctioned. No leak was found, and that is precisely what makes this decision noteworthy: a mere failure to protect data is enough to be sanctioned.
What the CNIL objects to
In its press release, the CNIL explains that it was alerted to the way the company stored the passwords for its customer area and the answers to the security questions used to access it, which triggered an inspection. The restricted committee, its body in charge of sanctions, found two breaches of the GDPR.
The first concerns security, under Article 32:
- customers’ passwords were stored in readable form, without being transformed by a hash function that prevents them from being read back;
- several employees shared the same credentials to access the customer databases and the tool used to consult them, which makes it impossible to know who did what.
The second concerns the retention period (Article 5): messages sent through the contact form were kept for more than ten years after the request had been handled, and connection data beyond the one year provided for by the company’s own internal policy.
1.8 million readable passwords
The CNIL does not give any volumes, but Next, drawing on the decision published on Légifrance, mentions around 1.8 million passwords allowing customers to open their personal area. The outlet points out that these personal areas may contain banking information such as RIBs (bank account details). The shared access account opened, again according to Next, a database of 1.3 million customers holding an ongoing life insurance contract, and it was used by eight people.
The timeline is long. According to Next, the authority was alerted in December 2023 and inspected the insurer’s premises in Niort in May 2024. The hearing before the restricted committee took place on 15 October 2026. The site specifies that the identification of Macif Vie is based on the report of that hearing published by MLex, as the decision only mentions a “company X”.
From €9 million to €5 million
The final amount is well below what the investigation had proposed. The rapporteur had initially sought €9 million, calculated on the parent company’s 2024 turnover, before lowering it to €7 million at the hearing after the company’s observations, Next reports. The restricted committee finally settled on €5 million, taking into account, according to the CNIL, the seriousness of the breaches, the number of people concerned and the company’s financial capacity.
The insurer corrected several points during the proceedings: stronger security, deletion of histories that were no longer needed and a monthly purge of customer data, the CNIL indicates. According to Next, however, state-of-the-art hashing was only put in place after the first sanction report, in April 2026. Macif, quoted by Siècle Digital, says it takes note of the decision, maintains that it cooperated and points out that no disclosure of these passwords was found. The restricted committee agreed not to name it, Next reports, with the CNIL considering that the statement of facts was sufficient for the educational purpose of its publication.
Why this decision concerns every company
The main lesson is simple: you do not need to have been hacked to be sanctioned. A password stored in plain text can be read by anyone who accesses the database, whether an employee, a contractor or an attacker. And if a customer has reused that same password elsewhere, a leak of the database would also expose their other accounts. Siècle Digital also considers the absence of disclosure significant given the number of cyberattacks in recent months.
The decision also recalls three rules that any organisation with a customer area can check quickly:
- passwords must never be stored in readable form, but transformed by a hash function;
- every access to sensitive databases must go through an individual account, the only way to trace actions in the event of an incident;
- data that no longer needs to be kept must be anonymised, archived if the law requires it, or deleted.
For small organisations, the sanction reads as a warning: the amount takes the company’s financial capacity into account, but the breaches found are within reach of any poorly configured online shop or members’ area.
Frequently asked questions
Why did the CNIL not name Macif?
The restricted committee considered that naming the company was not useful in this case, the statement of facts being sufficient for the educational purpose of the publication. The name was revealed by the press, and Macif confirmed to BFM Tech that it was concerned, according to Siècle Digital.
Should Macif Vie customers change their password?
No leak was found and, according to Next, compliant hashing was put in place after the April 2026 sanction report. As a precaution, however, a customer who uses that same password on other services would be well advised to replace it with a unique password.
What is a password “in plain text”?
It is a password stored exactly as the user typed it. A hash function transforms it into a fingerprint from which the original cannot be recovered, which makes it possible to verify a login without keeping the secret itself.
Sources
- Conservation des mots de passe clients en clair : la CNIL prononce une sanction de 5 millions d'euros — CNIL, 2026-11-18
- La CNIL sanctionne Macif Vie à hauteur de 5 millions d'euros pour des mots de passe en clair — Next, 2026-11-18
- La Macif écope de 5 millions d'euros d'amende pour avoir stocké des mots de passe en clair — Siècle Digital, 2026-11-18